LATIN VERDICT BONIXER CLO BONIXER 11 VERDICTS HARVEY CLEARED TYPE G GATE γ₁=14.134725141734693 γ₁ = 14.134725141734693
verdict-library clo-review set-bonixer meta-theorems
§1 — HOW THE BONIXER WORKS
The Latin Verdict Bonixer scores each scenario against the 11 verdict types using 5 assessment dimensions: Evidence quality (0-10), Entity status (EOSE Labs Inc. confirmed?), IP chain (clean?), Urgency (operational vs strategic), Prior ruling (exists?). The output is a ranked verdict list with the recommended verdict at top.
§2 — 5 ASSESSMENT DIMENSIONS
1
EVIDENCE QUALITY
How complete is the evidentiary record?
0 = no evidence
10 = full chain documented
2
ENTITY STATUS
Is the acting entity EOSE Labs Inc. with Amani GC + Harvey CLO sign-off?
YES / NO / PENDING
3
IP CHAIN
Is the IP assignment clean? Prior ruling? PRC jurisdiction risk?
YES / NO / UNCLEAR
4
URGENCY
Is this operational (immediate) or strategic (planned)?
OPERATIONAL / STRATEGIC / DEFERRED
5
PRIOR RULING
Does RES JUDICATA or STARE DECISIS apply?
YES (cite ruling) / NO
§3 — VERDICT SCORING MATRIX
EvidenceEntityIP ChainUrgencyPrior Ruling→ VERDICT
10YESYESOPERATIONAL—FIAT
10YESYESSTRATEGIC—PROBATUM EST / IMPRIMATUR
5–9YESUNCLEARany—NON LIQUET
anyanyanyanyYESRES JUDICATA / STARE DECISIS
anyNOanyany—MALA FIDE
anyBEYOND SCOPEanyany—ULTRA VIRES
anyYESanyROI LOW—NOLLE PROSEQUI
anyanyanyACTIVE REVIEW—SUB JUDICE
self-evidentYESYES (prior art)any—RES IPSA LOQUITUR
anyYESYESGOODWILL—EX GRATIA
§4 — SAMPLE SCENARIOS · 4 Worked Examples
Scenario A
"Contribute AGENTS.md pattern to anthropics/claude-code as EOSE Labs Inc."
📋 Evidence: 9/10 — prior art documented, production deployment exists
🏢 Entity: YES — EOSE Labs Inc., MT-003 applied
🔗 IP Chain: YES — SOUL.md + USER.md + MEMORY.md + SKILL.md in production
⚡ Prior Art: RES IPSA LOQUITUR — the implementation precedes the RFC
→ IMPRIMATUR + RES IPSA LOQUITUR note
Scenario B
"Contribute DeepSeek-V3 integration to fleet"
📋 Evidence: 8/10 — integration is technically viable
🏢 Entity: YES
🔗 IP Chain: UNCLEAR — PRC jurisdiction, export control unknown
⚖️ Prior ruling: Day 96 HOLD — deepseek-ai CLO HOLD in effect
→ RES JUDICATA prior CLO HOLD applies
Scenario C
"Submit PR as 'Kay Joffe' individual"
🏢 Entity: NO — individual, not EOSE Labs Inc.
🔗 MT-003 COI Duality: VIOLATED — individual bypass of entity gate
⚠️ IP protection: none — individual submissions carry no entity IP shield
📋 Result: contribution has no CLO backing, no IP assignment executed
→ MALA FIDE retract and refile as EOSE Labs Inc.
Scenario D
"Restore msi01 backup during production outage"
📋 Evidence: self-evident — production is down
🏢 Entity: YES — EOSE Labs Inc. SRE action
⚡ Urgency: OPERATIONAL — delay = further damage
✅ Authority: confirmed — SRE operational scope
→ FIAT immediate clearance, no further review